Critics’ Choice Awards 2026: The Night’s Top Triumphs and Shocking Snubs

The 31st Critics’ Choice Awards wrapped up at the Barker Hangar in Santa Monica, with Chelsea Handler returning as host for the fourth consecutive year. The evening was filled with both expected victories and jaw-dropping disappointments, as some stars walked away with new hardware while others left empty-handed.

Standout Victories That Defined the Night

Timothée Chalamet’s win for Best Actor in Marty Supreme was a highlight that few found surprising. His portrayal of table tennis legend Marty Reisman in Josh Safdie’s sports comedy has been widely celebrated, and this award season has only cemented his reputation. Chalamet, who had already generated Oscar buzz and earned a Golden Globe nod, finally took home his first Critics’ Choice trophy. During his acceptance speech, he addressed rumors about his relationship with Kylie Jenner, thanking her for her unwavering support:

“Thank you to my partner of three years. Thank you for our foundation. I love you. I couldn't do this without you.”

One Battle After Another claimed the Best Picture award, a win that many anticipated. Directed by Paul Thomas Anderson, this black comedy/action thriller starring Leonardo DiCaprio, Sean Penn, Regina Hall, and Benicio del Toro has been a critical darling, racking up nine Golden Globe nominations and setting the stage for a strong Oscar run.

Breakthroughs and First-Time Wins

Jacob Elordi earned his first major acting award, taking home Best Supporting Actor for his role as the Creature in Frankenstein. His performance stood out among a competitive field, and fans celebrated his well-deserved recognition. Elordi is also in the running for two Golden Globes this year, further highlighting his breakout year.

Miles Caton’s performance as Samuel “Sammie” Moore in Sinners earned him the Best Young Actor/Actress award. At just 20, Caton’s win was met with widespread approval, even as some questioned his eligibility due to age. The Critics’ Choice Association’s rules only require nominees to be under 21, making Caton’s victory legitimate and celebrated.

Rhea Seehorn finally secured her first Critics’ Choice Award after multiple nominations, winning Best Actress in a Drama Series for her role as Carol Sturka in the post-apocalyptic series Pluribus . Fans were thrilled to see her long-overdue recognition, with many expressing their excitement online:

“So happy Rhea’s getting the recognition she’s long deserved,”

and

“For me its the best moment of the night!!! She is the best!!!”

Unexpected Losses and Controversial Snubs

Despite its stunning visuals, Sinners lost the Best Cinematography award, leaving many fans disappointed. While Autumn Durald Arkapaw’s work was widely praised, the honor ultimately went to Train Dreams, a decision that sparked debate among viewers.

Pluribus was a strong contender for Best Drama Series, boasting a 98% approval rating and a thought-provoking storyline. However, the award went to The Pitt, prompting some to question the outcome. Still, Seehorn’s individual win offered some consolation to the show’s supporters.

Major Surprises and Fan Reactions

Wicked: For Good was nominated in seven categories, including Best Picture and Best Supporting Actress, but failed to secure a single win. The film ’s popularity and critical acclaim made its shutout one of the night’s biggest surprises, with many fans expressing their frustration online:

“critics choice awards really robbed wicked for good …”

Ryan Coogler, who poured his heart into directing Sinners, was passed over for Best Director in favor of Anderson for One Battle After Another. While Coogler’s film did win several other awards, the snub left some viewers disappointed:

“and ryan coogler snubbed for best director . . . .”

Adam Scott, nominated for Best Actor in a Drama Series for his role in Severance , also left the ceremony without a trophy. Fans took to social media to voice their dismay:

“the critics choice awards having a secret vendetta towards adam scott is crazy bc wtf he do to yall???”

and

“All I know is that Adam Scott going home empty handed for Severance all award season doesn’t sit right with me.”