Why Band of Brothers is better than The Pacific: one choice HBO made in 2001 and abandoned nine years later
Both HBO miniseries cost a fortune, won Outstanding Miniseries, and came from the same producers. One of them is structured so you always know who you're watching, and the other isn't — here's the decision that separates them.
Same network, same executive producers, same research budget, same Emmy category, same ten-episode shape. One of them is the show people rewatch every year, and the reason is a structural call made before a single frame was shot.
The call was this: Band of Brothers follows one unit. Easy Company, 2nd Battalion, 506th Parachute Infantry Regiment, 101st Airborne — from jump training at Camp Toccoa in 1942 to the Eagle's Nest in 1945. Every episode hands the point of view to a different man in that same company, which means the faces never reset. When somebody dies in episode 6, you have been watching him stand in formation since episode 1. The Pacific threw that out and followed three Marines in three different units, adapted from three different memoirs, who almost never share a scene.
The three-man split costs the audience its footing
The Pacific is built from Robert Leckie's Helmet for My Pillow, Eugene Sledge's With the Old Breed, and Chuck Tatum's Red Blood, Black Sand, with John Basilone as the third thread. James Badge Dale, Joseph Mazzello, and Jon Seda are all excellent. They are also, functionally, in three separate shows that cut between each other.
The practical effect is that every time the series builds momentum with one man, it leaves him for six weeks of screen time. Basilone goes home to sell war bonds. Leckie goes to a hospital on Banika. Sledge is still in Mobile, Alabama, not yet enlisted, while the other two are already fighting. Critics at the time called it disjointed, and the word stuck.
"The road to Berlin was a very linear undertaking, starting with Normandy and ending on Hitler's doorstep," Narrative First wrote in its structural breakdown of the two series. The Pacific had no equivalent line to walk.
Band of Brothers has Dick Winters as a fixed reference point across all ten hours even when he isn't the focus. The Pacific has no equivalent. Sledge comes closest, and he arrives late.
The second thing HBO dropped: the veterans
The 2001 series opens every episode with the real Easy Company men on camera, talking. They are not identified. You watch ten hours of testimony from old men in cardigans without knowing which of the characters you've been following each one grew into, and the names only appear in the finale.
Read more: Black Sheep Squadron: what happened to Gutterman? If you're rewatching and he's just gone, you didn't miss an episode
The Pacific replaced that device with historical introductions narrated by Tom Hanks — context about the campaign, not faces from it. It's informative. It is also the difference between a documentary frame and a briefing.
The numbers, for the record
- Budget — Band of Brothers cost $125 million, roughly $12.5 million per episode. The Pacific cost $217 million, the most expensive miniseries made at that point.
- Broadcast — Band of Brothers ran September 9 to November 4, 2001. The Pacific ran March 14 to May 16, 2010.
- Ratings — the 2001 premiere drew close to 10 million viewers; the finale drew 5.1 million after HBO pulled its marketing following September 11. The Pacific opened at 3.08 million and finished at 1.81 million.
- Critics — 94% on Rotten Tomatoes and 87 on Metacritic for Band of Brothers; 89% on Rotten Tomatoes for The Pacific.
- Awards — seven Emmys plus a Golden Globe for the first; Outstanding Miniseries for the second.
What The Pacific got right anyway
It is the more honest show about what the fighting did to the men doing it. Sledge's arc through Peleliu and Okinawa is more psychologically detailed than anything in the European series, and the homecoming material in the final episode is better written than the equivalent in 2001. Where Band of Brothers ends with a unit that survived together, The Pacific ends with three men who were never a unit at all and cannot explain themselves to anyone at home.
That ending is truer to the Pacific campaign. It is also why the series is admired more than it is rewatched.
For the record: both were produced by Steven Spielberg, Tom Hanks, and Gary Goetzman, and both used surviving veterans as consultants. The 2010 series simply asked its audience to do the work of holding three unrelated men in mind for ten hours, and most of that audience declined.
Earlier we wrote: House of the Dragon: Green vs Black, who wins? If you're rooting for a queen or a king, you've already lost