What is The Knick based on? A real Manhattan hospital, and a surgeon whose addiction was no invention
The Cinemax drama takes its name from an institution that really existed in New York, and builds its chief surgeon out of a documented medical career. What the writers took from the record, and what they moved, renamed, or invented outright.
The Knick opens with a surgeon timing himself against a stopwatch while a woman bleeds out in front of a paying audience. The unnerving part is how little of that the writers had to make up.
Created by Jack Amiel and Michael Begler and directed in full — all 20 episodes, both seasons — by Steven Soderbergh, the series premiered on Cinemax on 8 August 2014 and is set in New York in 1900 and 1901. The Knickerbocker Hospital was a real place. Dr. John Thackery was not, but the man underneath him was.
The hospital existed. The address didn't.
The real Knickerbocker started life in 1862 as the Manhattan Dispensary, a tent operation treating Union soldiers coming back from the Civil War. It was rebuilt as Manhattan Hospital, which the New York Times in 1885 described as the only general hospital north of 99th Street. In 1895 it was renamed for James Hood Wright, a Philadelphia railroad man who worked for J.P. Morgan and who had collapsed at the Rector Street elevated station the previous November and never regained consciousness.
The name in the title arrived in 1913 — thirteen years after the series is set — when the 228-bed hospital moved to 70 Convent Avenue at West 131st Street in Harlem. It ran the largest ambulance district in the city, from 77th to 145th Street and Fifth Avenue to the Hudson. It became Arthur C. Logan Memorial Hospital in 1974 and closed in 1979, $20 million in debt. The building is now a senior residence.
The hospital was real. It just wasn't called the Knickerbocker yet, and it was ten miles uptown from where Soderbergh puts it.
Thackery is William Stewart Halsted, barely disguised
Clive Owen has said as much himself. Halsted graduated from Columbia's College of Physicians and Surgeons in 1877 and, in 1884, read Carl Koller's report on cocaine as an eye anesthetic. He began injecting it into himself and his students, established the nerve block, and published the results in 1885. Several of the students became addicts. So did he.
A recuperative sailing trip to the Windward Islands failed when he broke into the captain's cabinet for the cocaine he'd deliberately under-packed. In May 1886 he checked into Butler Hospital in Providence, signing the logbook as "William Stewart," and stayed six months. He went back in 1887 for nine more. The treatment was morphine. It worked, in the sense that the cocaine stopped and the morphine never did — William Osler's private history of Johns Hopkins records him still being treated for it in 1898.
Read more: How much did Band of Brothers cost to make? The 2001 figure set a miniseries record that stood for nearly a decade
He became one of the four founding physicians at Johns Hopkins, surgeon-in-chief in 1890, and the man credited with the radical mastectomy and with introducing rubber gloves to the operating room. The gloves were not an infection-control measure. Halsted wrote that his scrub nurse complained the mercuric chloride solutions "produced a dermatitis of her arms and hands"; he ordered two pairs from the Goodyear Rubber Company. The nurse was Caroline Hampton. They married later that year. He died in 1922.
The rest of the call sheet
- Dr. Algernon Edwards — drawn largely from Louis T. Wright, who finished fourth in his Harvard Medical School class in 1915 and became the first Black surgeon on the staff of a non-segregated New York hospital. Wright was nine years old in 1900; Daniel Hale Williams is the other commonly cited model.
- "Get the Rope" — the season 1 riot episode reworks the Tenderloin riot of August 1900, when plainclothes officer Robert J. Thorpe accosted May Enoch and was stabbed by her partner Arthur Harris. Thorpe died; mobs went after Black New Yorkers across the district. The show swaps in the fictional Officer Sears.
- Dr. Henry Cotton — real, and played by John Hodgman. His teeth-pulling cure for mental illness was actual practice at the New Jersey State Hospital at Trenton, though a couple of decades later than the show has it.
- Typhoid Mary — Mary Mallon wasn't traced or quarantined until 1907. The writers pulled her forward seven years.
- Lucy Elkins, Cornelia Robertson, Tom Cleary — invented.
Soderbergh's team worked from the Burns Archive and Columbia's medical archives, and some of the props on screen are direct replicas of instruments in the collection. The 100-second placenta previa operation in the pilot, performed for a gallery of spectators, is the kind of thing that reads as invention and isn't.
Earlier we wrote: Little House on the Prairie cast: who is still alive? With the Netflix reboot out, a full check on the original Walnut Grove actors