Sebastian Stan Eyed for The Batman 2 After Riddler Dream
Sebastian Stan is reportedly in talks for a major role in The Batman: Part II, sparking fan theories about which character he might play. Discover what Stan once revealed about his dream DC villain and how the sequel’s casting rumors are shaking up expectations.
Recent buzz suggests Sebastian Stan is negotiating to join Matt Reeves’s The Batman: Part II, with reports indicating he could star opposite Robert Pattinson ’s caped crusader in a yet-to-be-revealed role. As speculation swirled, fans revisited a 2024 interview where Stan opened up about his interest in Gotham’s rogues’ gallery.
Stan’s Fascination With Gotham’s Villains
During a conversation on the Happy Sad Confused podcast, Stan was asked if he’d ever consider stepping into a non-Marvel superhero universe. He admitted he’s always been drawn to the darker corners of the Batman mythos, especially one particular villain. In his own words:
I don’t know if Batman’s for me, but never say never. I don’t know. There’s so many characters — I told you, I always had a soft spot for that Riddler, but that one’s been done.
Despite his interest, Stan won’t be donning the green suit of The Riddler in Reeves’s Elseworlds saga, as Paul Dano already brought the character to life in the first film and is expected to return.
Other Big Names Circling The Batman Sequel
Stan isn’t the only Marvel alum rumored for the highly anticipated sequel. Reports have also linked Scarlett Johansson to a significant part, while Tobias Menzies is said to be in the running for Amadeus Arkham. There’s even been chatter about Brad Pitt, though it ’s unlikely he’ll take on a supporting role.
Meanwhile, Zoë Kravitz, who played Selina Kyle, is reportedly not returning for the follow-up. However, Jeffrey Wright and Andy Serkis are set to reprise their roles as Commissioner Gordon and Alfred Pennyworth. Barry Keoghan is expected to have a bigger presence as The Joker, and Paul Dano may once again appear as The Riddler. Colin Farrell will return as Oz Cobb, following his lead role in The Penguin series, but Cristin Milioti’s Sofia Falcone may not be back.
Breaking Free From Villain Typecasting
Stan’s acting journey began as a child in 71 Fragments of a Chronology of Chance, but his early career often saw him cast as troubled or antagonistic characters. He played a menacing teen in Law & Order, and later took on villainous roles in The Covenant and Hot Tub Time Machine. Even in shows like Gossip Girl and Kings, he was often the bad boy.
By the time he landed the role of Bucky Barnes, Stan was eager to break out of the villain mold. He once told Flaunt Magazine:
I seem to keep ending up with these bad boy characters. I don’t understand what’s going on. I walk the street in New York feeling like I’m Paul Rudd or something, but apparently no one else sees it that way.
Over time, Stan’s roles became more nuanced, especially as Bucky’s arc evolved in the MCU. He’s since branched out with diverse performances in projects like Pam & Tommy, The Martian, Fresh, Sharper, A Different Man, and The Apprentice.
The Batman: Part II is slated for release on October 1, 2027.