How does The Knick end? Season 2 was the last, though Soderbergh had the next one planned
Steven Soderbergh's Cinemax drama The Knick stopped after 20 episodes, and its finale remains one of the most discussed endings in the medical-drama genre. Here's how the second season closed every storyline, what the planned continuation looked like, and where the revival talk stands today.
The Knick ends on December 18, 2015, with "This Is All We Are" — an episode in which Dr. John Thackery books the operating theater, fills the gallery with colleagues, and performs surgery on himself. It goes about as well as self-surgery on cocaine can go.
That was episode 20 of 20. Every one of them directed by Steven Soderbergh, and the ending was locked in before the star even signed.
Thackery's exit
Clive Owen's Thackery, his intestines wrecked by years of cocaine and heroin, refuses to let anyone else at the Knickerbocker operate on him. Mid-procedure, under spinal anesthesia and narrating his own work to the audience, he makes one cut too many and bleeds out on the table.
Read more: A modern twist on an Agatha Christie classic: Tommy & Tuppence cast, plot, release date
The shock was planned from day one. Soderbergh told Indiewire in 2015 that he'd warned Owen before shooting anything:
"We are going to kill you at the end of Season 2, just so you know," Soderbergh recalled saying. Owen's reported reply: good to know.
Owen only agreed to television on a two-season commitment, so the death was baked into the contract as much as the script.
Everyone else's ending
The finale scatters the rest of the cast with unusual thoroughness:
- Cornelia — discovers her brother Henry set the ship fire that killed their father, gets threatened by him at the top of a staircase, and boards a boat to Australia.
- Dr. Edwards — left with permanent eye damage from Gallinger's sucker punch, which effectively ends his surgical career trajectory.
- Gallinger — faces zero consequences and sails to Europe to lecture on eugenics, itinerary starting in Germany. Subtle, it is not.
- Barrow — wriggles out of the arson investigation through connections and paperwork, keeps the money.
- Lucy — marries into the Robertson fortune, passing Cornelia on the stairs on her way up.
The season 3 that existed on paper
Cinemax ordered a script for a third-season premiere within days of the finale. Soderbergh's larger design, described to Variety, was a six-season show that reset every two years — season 3 would jump 20 years ahead to the 1920s, then jump again, tracking medicine's progress across decades. At one point the plan had new filmmakers taking over; at another, Soderbergh directing every episode himself. Cinemax canceled the whole thing in March 2017, citing a pivot toward action dramas.
The revival that refuses to die
In 2020, Soderbergh confirmed to The Playlist that Barry Jenkins and André Holland had taken over a new version, with creators Jack Amiel and Michael Begler writing a pilot centered on Holland's Dr. Edwards.
"I had my shot. Godspeed, take it in whatever direction you want," Soderbergh said of handing it to Jenkins.
Holland told TheWrap at Sundance in January 2024 that scripts exist, Jenkins remains attached, and the only missing piece is a studio willing to write the check. Begler has separately confirmed a spinoff pilot set in 1919 Harlem. Ten years after Thackery's last operation, the patient is technically still on the table.
Earlier we wrote: Nathan Fielder’s A24 doc ‘A Secret’ spotlights Elizabeth Holmes—here’s who she is