From Virgin River to Sullivan's Crossing: The Cast Crossovers You Might Have Missed

If you watch both Virgin River and Sullivan's Crossing and keep thinking, wait, I know that face — you do. Robyn Carr wrote the books both shows are based on, and while the towns don’t exist in the same world, the casting department clearly shops on the same aisle.Two different towns, same creator, lots of familiar facesSullivan's Crossing is a Canadian drama based on Carr’s novels. It ’s a CTV series up north, aired in the U.S. on The CW first, and later landed on Netflix. The story follows neurosurgeon Maggie (Morgan Kohan), who retreats to her hometown in rural Nova Scotia, butting heads and making peace with her estranged dad Sully (Scott Patterson) and stumbling into romance with Cal (Chad Michael Murray). The ensemble also includes Tom Jackson, Andrea Menard, Dakota Taylor, Amalia Williamson and Lindura. Virgin River is Netflix’s long-running small-town soap set in Northern California. It centers on nurse practitioner/midwife Mel (Alexandra Breckenridge) and bar owner Jack (Martin Henderson), plus a deep bench of regulars: Colin Lawrence, Annette O'Toole, Tim Matheson, Benjamin Hollingsworth, Sarah Dugdale, Zibby Allen, Marco Grazzini and Kai Bradbury.About that crossover talkThere isn’t an official crossover — these are separate book series set in different places — but some of the Virgin River cast wouldn’t mind engineering a meet-cute between the shows. Benjamin Hollingsworth (Brady) told Us Weekly in March 2026 that he’s all in on the idea and that the renewed appetite for romance dramas makes the timing perfect. "We have to, right? I think that’s perfect and that would be amazing. I love that romance drama is really having a comeback and it’s gotten such momentum there." Marco Grazzini said a team-up makes sense since the audiences already overlap, and he’s curious what kind of storylines writers would cook up. Zibby Allen was game too — she can easily picture it and, yes, she loves a crossover scenario. Translation: the actors are ready if the networks and rights holders ever decide to play ball.Why these towns feel connected anywayRobyn Carr has talked about why her worlds click on TV: she builds settings that feel lived-in and a little unforgiving. Back in 2020, she wrote for BookBub that her towns always have the basics — homes, businesses, a church, medical and emergency services, and a go-to hangout like a diner, coffeehouse or bar and grill — plus farms and ranches beyond the town line. The vibe isn’t quaint so much as rugged and remote; these places are beautiful, but they’re not easy. So even without an official crossover, Virgin River and Sullivan’s Crossing share a DNA you can feel.Who’s pulling double dutyLauren Hammersley: Charmaine on Virgin River; Connie on Sullivan's Crossing Lynda Boyd: Lily on Virgin River; Phoebe on Sullivan's Crossing John Ralston: Roland on Virgin River; Jed on Sullivan's Crossing

From Virgin River to Sullivan's Crossing: The Cast Crossovers You Might Have Missed

Read also