Amanda Seyfried’s You Can See Everything role: what Billy Evans finally says
Billy Evans isn’t pulling punches about Amanda Seyfried’s Elizabeth Holmes in A24’s documentary You Can See Everything.
Pressed on whether Amanda Seyfried “played Elizabeth Holmes well,” Billy Evans didn’t exactly hand out compliments. In a televised sit-down with Matt Gutman, Holmes’ partner and the CEO of Haemanthus first offered, “I was glad Nathan was there to help her ,” before drawing a hard line between Holmes and the portrayal that made Seyfried an Emmy winner.
“I’m really glad that they included her because it shows what a difference there is between the real thing and how eager she was to play a character.”
Evans’ on-camera swipe landed after Seyfried described her own uncomfortable encounter with him during filming. She told Rolling Stone her opinion of Evans “only got worse” after they met, recounting a tense dinner where he criticized her acting and she pressed him on how he treated Holmes, his longtime partner and the mother of his children.
Evans also said he was “glad Nathan was there to help her.”
How Seyfried ended up in the room
You Can See Everything began with directors Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim embedding inside the Northern California home Holmes shared with Evans for 34 days, capturing the final stretch before she reported to prison in 2023. What started as a contained shoot expanded into a three-year project as the filmmakers kept following the couple.
Seyfried joined later, after Fielder and Oppenheim reconsidered how to approach their footage. Her return to the role she played in Hulu ’s The Dropout added an intentionally disorienting layer, blurring straight nonfiction with a reenactment vibe—and, as Evans’ comments make clear, inviting friction between the “real” Holmes and the version viewers know from TV.
The film tracks Holmes and Evans through the lead-up to her incarceration, focusing on their domestic life with the fallout from the Theranos fraud conviction never far away. It’s an unusually intimate—and purposely meta—portrait that turns a private household into a documentary set.