16 Years On, South Park’s Most Notorious Episode Is Still Banned
Born as a crude construction-paper short traded on VHS—complete with a Jesus vs. Santa slugfest over Christmas—South Park shot from underground oddity to TV’s gleeful provocateur, and it still delights in pushing every button.
South Park has been poking the bear since before it was even a TV show. We’re talking scissors, construction paper, VHS tapes passed hand to hand, and a short where Jesus and Santa literally throw down over who owns Christmas. From there: day-one chaos like ‘Cartman Gets an Anal Probe,’ then ‘Mecha-Streisand’ a few weeks later. Twenty-eight seasons in, the show still hasn’t learned the meaning of ‘maybe don’t.’
Why today matters
April 21, 2010 — sixteen years ago today — is the one time South Park got censored on its very first airing. The episode was ‘201’ (yes, the 201st episode), a direct sequel to the previous week’s ‘200’ and a big knot-tying exercise that pulled threads from all over the series. It also brought the Prophet Muhammad into the plot in a way that drew death threats against Trey Parker and Matt Stone and pushed the network’s corporate parents to step in and bleep, blur, and bury the thing.
Quick rewind: how ‘200’ set the fuse
In ‘200,’ a mob of angry celebrities threatens to sue the town. Their terms to make it all go away: deliver the Prophet Muhammad. The town balks, because depicting Muhammad is widely considered forbidden in Islam and, more to the point, people feared it could spark violence. The episode never actually shows him — he’s a voice behind a door or hidden inside a giant costume — and the cliffhanger tees up ‘201’ like it’s going to finally show the character outright.
Here’s the twist: South Park had already depicted Muhammad years earlier, in Season 5’s ‘Super Best Friends,’ and no one blinked at the time. But by 2010, the climate around that topic had changed. A now-defunct radical group out of New York called Revolution Muslim posted a warning suggesting Parker and Stone could ‘wind up like Theo Van Gogh’ — the Dutch filmmaker murdered after releasing a short critical of how women are treated in Islam. Between that threat and a broader industry stance of ‘just don’t go there,’ the episode became a flashpoint before it even aired.
The night the network blinked
‘201’ pulled bigger ratings than ‘200’ because everyone wanted to see what South Park would do. What they saw: heavy-handed censorship. Every spoken mention of ‘Muhammad’ was bleeped. The character was covered with a giant black bar labeled ‘Censored.’ And the episode’s final moral-of-the-story monologue? Sliced to pieces — over 30 seconds of audio wiped, multiple characters included.
Some viewers assumed the bleeps were the gag. They weren’t. The next day, the South Park team said the censorship was added after they delivered the episode to the network — specifically, that Comedy Central added the bleeps. They also called out that Kyle’s big closing line, which was explicitly about fear and intimidation, got silenced too. Here’s the line uncensored:
"