Paul Thomas Anderson Reveals His Dream Cast of Hollywood Legends

Few filmmakers can claim to have worked with acting giants like Daniel Day-Lewis, Philip Seymour Hoffman, and Joaquin Phoenix, but for Paul Thomas Anderson, that’s just the beginning. Known for his ambitious storytelling and ability to draw out unforgettable performances, Anderson has carved out a reputation as one of the most influential directors of his era. His filmography spans everything from the darkly comedic world of 'Boogie Nights' to the sweeping drama of 'There Will Be Blood,' each project marked by a distinct vision and a knack for assembling remarkable casts.

Despite his impressive roster of collaborators, Anderson’s wish list extends far beyond the living. During a Reddit Ask Me Anything in 2017, he was asked which actors from the past he’d resurrect for a chance to work together. His response was immediate and enthusiastic:

“Oh! Oh! Humphrey [Bogart]. Cary Grant. Ida Lupino. Joan Fontaine. Charles Laughton. Myrna Loy. Carole Lombard. James Mason!!!!!!! We don’t have enough time to play this game. Jason Robards!”

Golden Age Icons and Their Lasting Impact

Anderson’s choices read like a who’s who of classic Hollywood. Humphrey Bogart and Cary Grant, two of the era’s most recognizable faces, brought entirely different energies to the screen—Bogart with his world-weary wit, Grant with his effortless sophistication. Their inclusion highlights Anderson’s appreciation for range and charisma in his performers.

He also named Joan Fontaine, a star often overshadowed by her contemporaries, and Ida Lupino, whose legacy as a pioneering female director sometimes eclipses her acting career. Lupino broke barriers as the first woman to direct a film noir, making her a particularly intriguing pick for a director who values both performance and vision.

Comedic Geniuses and Versatile Talents

Myrna Loy and Carole Lombard, both celebrated for their work in screwball comedies of the 1930s, also made Anderson’s list. Their sharp timing and magnetic screen presence helped define an entire genre, and Anderson’s nod to them—over more commonly cited names like Katharine Hepburn—shows his deep appreciation for the subtleties of comedic performance.

Charles Laughton, remembered primarily as an actor, also made a significant mark as a director with his only film, 'The Night of the Hunter.' This haunting classic has inspired generations of filmmakers, and Anderson’s admiration for Laughton’s dual talents is clear.

Unrealized Collaborations and Lasting Inspirations

James Mason, known for his refined yet slightly menacing roles in films like 'North by Northwest' and 'Lolita,' is another actor Anderson would have loved to direct. Imagining Mason in one of Anderson’s transformative roles is a tantalizing thought, especially given the director’s history of reinventing actors’ careers.

Finally, Anderson mentioned Jason Robards, with whom he actually worked on 'Magnolia' in 1999. The experience left such a strong impression that Anderson still wishes for another chance to collaborate, underscoring the profound impact these legendary performers have had on his creative journey.