How a Holiday Flop With Chalamet Led to Seyfried’s Razzie Nod
Before Timothée Chalamet’s rise to stardom, he and Amanda Seyfried shared the screen in a holiday movie that missed the mark. Discover how this early misstep impacted Seyfried’s career and why Chalamet’s latest role has everyone talking about his Oscar chances.
Timothée Chalamet is making headlines these days for his standout performance in Josh Safdie’s Marty Supreme, which just earned him a Critics’ Choice Award. But rewind to 2015, and you’ll find Chalamet in a very different place—appearing in the little-remembered holiday film Love the Coopers. The movie, which failed to impress critics or audiences, also featured Amanda Seyfried in a supporting role, a surprising move for an actress with her track record.
From Acclaimed Roles to a Holiday Misfire
Amanda Seyfried, who broke out with Mean Girls in 2004 and went on to star in hits like Mamma Mia!, Les Misérables, and Mank, took on the part of Ruby, a troubled waitress, in Love the Coopers. The film boasted a star-studded cast, including Diane Keaton, Marisa Tomei, Alan Arkin, and John Goodman, but it couldn’t overcome its lackluster script and direction. With a Rotten Tomatoes score of just 19%, the movie quickly faded from memory, despite its holiday theme and ensemble lineup.
In the story, Seyfried’s character forms a connection with Alan Arkin’s Bucky and shares a brief romantic subplot with Ed Helms’ Hank. Even with limited screen time, Seyfried’s performance drew harsh criticism, leading to an unexpected low point in her career.
Seyfried’s Razzie Nomination and the Film’s Legacy
In 2016, Seyfried found herself nominated for a Razzie Award, which spotlights the year’s most disappointing performances. She appeared on the list alongside Kaley Cuoco, Rooney Mara, Michelle Monaghan, and Julianne Moore. For an actress known for her strong filmography, this nomination stood out as a rare misstep.
Love the Coopers tried to deliver a quirky, heartwarming holiday story but ultimately missed the mark. Despite the efforts of its cast, the film is now mostly remembered for its critical failure and the surprising Razzie nod for Seyfried. The movie’s runtime clocks in at 1 hour and 47 minutes, and it remains available to stream on Hulu and AMC+.
Chalamet’s Career Turnaround and Oscar Buzz
Fast forward to 2026, and both Chalamet and Seyfried have moved far beyond their Love the Coopers days. Seyfried recently earned a Critics’ Choice nomination for Best Actress for her role in The Testament of Ann Lee. Meanwhile, Chalamet took home the Critics’ Choice Award for his work in Marty Supreme, fueling speculation about his chances at the upcoming Oscars.
The Critics’ Choice Awards often hint at potential Oscar winners, but the outcome is never certain. In recent years, some actors have won both awards, like Adrien Brody for The Brutalist in 2025 and Brendan Fraser for The Whale in 2023. However, there have also been surprises—Paul Giamatti won the Critics’ Choice for The Holdovers in 2024, but Cillian Murphy took the Oscar for Oppenheimer. The same happened in 2021, when Chadwick Boseman won the Critics’ Choice, but Anthony Hopkins claimed the Academy Award.
With Chalamet’s acclaimed performance in Marty Supreme and strong competition from Leonardo DiCaprio and Michael B. Jordan, the race for the Oscar remains wide open. His fans are eager to see if this will finally be the year he takes home the coveted statue.