40 Years Later: The Iconic Sitcom That Signed Off on a Cliffhanger—What Really Happened Next?

TV loves a good cliffhanger. It loves them less when the network pulls the plug before anyone gets an answer. And 40 years ago today, ABC did exactly that to Benson.The rare sitcom that went full cliffhangerGenre shows leaving fans hanging? Sure. Sitcoms doing it? Way less common. Most multi-cams are relatively cheap, steady performers, and they usually get to land the plane on their own terms. Think Seinfeld, Cheers, The Big Bang Theory. Meanwhile, plenty of dramas and genre series have taken a final bow mid-gasp:Sliders and Alf both wrapped with unresolved endings Angel ended on a huge question mark that only got resolved in comics The streaming era sped the churn up: Netflix alone has left cliffhangers on Archive 81, Glow, I Am Not Okay With This, Santa Clarita Diet, and The OA Quick refresher: what Benson was actually aboutSpun off from Soap, Benson starred Robert Guillaume as Benson DuBois, the quick-witted household manager for a state governor. James Noble played Governor Eugene X. Gatling, a sweet, slightly oblivious widower raising a teenage daughter. The show ping-ponged between: - Straight-up political plots (there is an episode where the state budget director dies suddenly) - Classic sitcom stuff (Benson trying to keep a local street gang out of trouble) - And the occasional curveball (the governor becomes convinced Benson was abducted by a UFO during a golf outing)How Benson built to the big non-endingBy Season 7, Benson had moved up to Lieutenant Governor, working alongside his old boss. As the finale approached, Benson ran for governor himself under the assumption Gatling was term-limited out. Then a loophole surfaced: if Gatling ran as a third-party candidate, he could go again. They both jumped in, friendship strained but intact. The finale even had the perfect title: 'And the Winner Is...' Benson and Gatling patched things up and waited for the results together. Cue the drumroll... and cut to black. ABC canceled the show before anyone said who won. That was April 19, 1986. Brutal.What would have happened next? Depends who you askShowrunner Bob Fraser later said the cliffhanger itself was ABC's idea. In a 2007 TV Series Finale interview, he laid out the intended path forward: Gatling squeaks out a narrow victory; the junior senator from their still-unnamed state dies in office; Gatling appoints Benson to fill the Senate seat; a domino run of accidents and oddities shuffles the national line of succession until Benson becomes President of the United States. One catch: that piece did not include direct quotes from Fraser, so consider it informed scuttlebutt rather than gospel.The director's very different versionGary Brown, who directed the finale, told Salon in 2008 that they actually filmed three outcomes: Benson wins, Gatling wins, and a third, 'whimsical' ending where the race ends in a tie. Brown believed that, regardless of which card they flipped first, Benson would have become governor eventually, in part because Robert Guillaume wanted that for the character. Brown also pointed out that ABC kept bouncing Benson around the schedule season to season, and the audience still managed to find it each time. As he put it: 'The never-fulfilled resolution to the cliffhanger - which we will never know for sure but which Brown believes would have resulted in the culmination of a seasons-long journey - might well have put gas in the tank for seasons to come... It would have given the show new life.' Why it ended anywayThe short version: money. After seven seasons, production costs were high and only heading higher, and ABC pulled the plug. So on April 19, 1986, Benson left viewers mid-suspense, an oddball entry in the tiny club of sitcoms that dared to cut to black without an answer.The takeawayIf you were there, the lack of resolution probably still stings. The small comfort is that we at least know the two competing roads not taken: either Benson wins outright (eventually), or he loses narrowly and still climbs the ladder in a wildly roundabout way. Either version fits the show: pragmatic, a little idealistic, and always ready to outmaneuver the chaos.

40 Years Later: The Iconic Sitcom That Signed Off on a Cliffhanger—What Really Happened Next?

Read also